Community

Gig Harbor Now and Then | This letter from 1939 foreshadowed modern social media commenters

Posted on November 16th, 2026 By:

Things have been happening at the old Spadoni Brothers office at the corner of Rosedale Street and Stinson Avenue in Gig Harbor, which was Gig Harbor Now and Then Location of Mystery No. 3, back in August. The side of the building that faces Stinson Avenue was recently reclaimed from the encroaching jungle vines that had been taking over. If you look closely, you can vaguely see some old red lettering underneath the gray paint.

Photo by Tonya Strickland.

This is a full view of what’s under that gray paint:

Notice the left eyes of that same old junk car from a June 17, 2026, photo peeking from behind the right side of the building. Photo by Greg Spadoni.

Wouldn’t it be cool if they removed the rest of that drab, gray paint?

New old business

Four score and seven years ago, our newspaper forefathers brought forth to this community a controversy over a short news article about a dance in Rosedale. It played out through an anger-driven and sharply-worded exchange of letters to the editor of The Peninsula Gateway.

Someone who preferred to remain nameless had his feelings hurt over a three-word phrase in an article reporting on a well-attended dance at the Rosedale Community Hall. Can you spot the offending three words?

From July 21, 1939:

The Gay Summer Crowd Holds Dance at Rosedale 

New residents, summer people, the U.S. Navy, a splendid orchestra and some of the younger married people of Gig Harbor joined with the dancing crowd at Rosedale at the Rosedale Community Hall last Saturday night in a box social and dance which netted the hall about 40 dollars.

After naming the organizers and some of the attendees, the article continued:

The Brown orchestra from Seattle brought by Mrs. Pierret served a rare brand of dance music: staid lawyers, navy officers, business men and the lower Rosedale crowd whooped it up with wholesome fun and if anyone was worried for the fear the Mars men were attacking our usually quiet community, they may be assured it was the summer folks interpretation of the Lambeth Walk.

The mention of Mars men is an obvious reference to Orson Welles’ radio production of The War of the Worlds the previous October. The Lambeth Walk was a contemporary dance craze.

After saying the dance was such a success that it would “doubtless be repeated later in the summer,” the writer closed with an apparently light-hearted comment on the meal served:

Are there any chickens left in Rosedale? Most of us are ashamed to look a chicken in the face and we jump when we hear a rooster crow, but they were good.

This article from the July 21, 1939, Peninsula Gateway was accessed at the Harbor History Museum.

A single-question quiz

Did you spot the offending three words?

They are “lower Rosedale crowd.”

The anonymous author of the letter in protest was upset that some of the new inhabitants of Rosedale, along with the summer-only people, were slowly taking over from the “longer established residents.” His breaking point was the article’s reference to some of the longer-established residents as “the lower Rosedale crowd.” After stating the evils of the new and part-time residents of the community, he gave a short lesson in journalism:

One of the fundamentals of journalism is the construction of simple but lucid phrases and sentences. If another meaning was intended, the writer displayed a surprising lack of knowledge of correct phraseology.

He proceeded to explain what really galled him:

As we understand it, this was an invitational affair. Then is it not adding insult to injury, this accepting, or rather, soliciting the local peoples money, and then neatly disposing of them, publicly, as belonging in a lower social bracket than the newer residents, summer and out of town guests?

Next, he stated his view of what a resolution to the offensive remark should look like:

Such a classification can only lead to misunderstanding and resentment on the part of the local citizenry, and we suggest that an immediate retraction be made, or at least an explanation of this uncalled for stupidity.

He signed his letter “From One of the Lower Rosedale Crowd.”

This article from the July 28, 1939, Peninsula Gateway was accessed at the Harbor History Museum.

It’s too bad Mr. Anonymous hadn’t simply asked for a clarification of the offending phrase instead of attacking the writer. The man who wrote the article was Edwin Van Deusen Paul, a full-time Rosedale resident and part-time professional writer, who took the opportunity to reply with three times as many column inches on Aug. 4. He pulled no punches when he said of Mr. Anonymous:

[The complainant] reached the height of stupidity, cowardice and ingratitude. Stupid, because his findings were not true; cowardly, because an anonymous letter of vicious, untrue criticism always means the writer tries to strike in the dark; afraid to sign his or her own name. Ungrateful, because the untruth struck at our new residents and summer people who had just shown their interest in a local project and had made a splendid contribution to the welfare of the community, by donating thirty six dollars to the Rosedale Community Hall, a sum much needed at this time, and gratefully appreciated by all the hall members …

The letter is meaningless because it is a falsehood from a source hidden in shame behind a nom-de-plume to cover up a coward.

After a few paragraphs in praise of the summer residents and newcomers of Rosedale, Mr. Paul again railed against Mr. Anonymous:

The good people of Rosedale have been embarrassed by the brainstorm outburst of this unknown, discredited, anonomous [sic] poison pen blurb who is ashamed to sign his name. 

… The rent of the Rosedale Community Hall is three dollars a night … [the new and summer group] contributed thirty six dollars; twelve times the usual rent.

… Any slap given these people by one disgruntled, non dancing, member, a sour puss who hates to see others enjoy themselves, is deeply resented by the Rosedale people. 

… The height of meanness or stupidity was shown by him, when through ignorance or a second grade comprehension of the English language, which he presumably knows, he stupidly misquotes from the article describing the dance in the Gateway of July 21, which I wrote and from which I retract not a single word.

Mr. Paul went on to explain to Mr. Anonymous what he meant by the “lower Rosedale crowd.”

We all know that Rosedale, generally speaking, extends from Horsehead Bay to Purdy, and its component parts are often referred to as Upper and Lower or North and South Rosedale. I said in my article “staid lawyers, navy officers, business men and the lower Rosedale crowd whooped it up with wholesome fun, etc.” What a lack of brain anyone must have to construe a location, (lower Rosedale) to mean that all the crowd at the dance belonged to a lower order of society. Yet that anonomous letter said just that. A child in the third grade would be spanked for ignorance like that and all Rosedale now feels a sorry contempt for him. 

… we most earnestly regret the silly incident, and hope the anonomous writer, who has a contempt for truth and facts, will not offend them further.

I am proud to be one of the lower Rosedale crowd and not ashamed to sign, E.V.D. Paul

All in all, ouch!

Past is prologue

While quite hostile, that nasty exchange between Mr. Anonymous and Mr. Paul used very clean language compared to what is now considered routine for a million daily angry exchanges on the Internet. But it shows how easily people could be ruffled 87 years ago, just as they can be — and regularly are — today. The only reason written confrontation wasn’t as common then as it is today is the cooling effect of having to hand write or type a letter on paper, put it in an envelope, pay for postage, drop it in the mail, and wait a week to see if the editor published it.

Today you can respond in seconds, while you’re still boiling mad and not thinking straight. And you can freely use all the filthiest, nastiest words you can think of.

The evolution from slow, stamped envelope to real-time, uncensored keyboard in your pocket is called progress.

I don’t know what the degradation in civility is called.

P.S.

Mr. Paul added a postscript to his reply to Mr. Anonymous.

P.S. Mr. Trombley like all good publishers naturally opens his columns to letters, and he certainly assumed no responsibility to the letter appearing in the Gateway July 28. Let’s hope there will be nothing further said on the matter.

  1. V. D. P.

There wasn’t. At least not in the Gateway.

This article from the August 4, 1939, Peninsula Gateway was accessed at the Harbor History Museum.

New business: the power of instant recognition

Sometimes you don’t need more than a fraction of a second to recognize something or someone. You know what or who it is instantly. Or, so you think.

Take a look at this picture from an old Peninsula Gateway:

At first glance, I recognized it as a very famous singer/musician from the early days of rock & roll.

What do you think?

Whoever it may be, this picture is of Gig Harbor Now and Then Person of Mystery No. 1.

Do you need multiple guesses? Or, like me, do you think you recognized the person instantly?

We’ll find out the identity of Person of Mystery No. 1 on Nov. 30.

— Greg Spadoni, November 16, 2026